Hmmm so the first thing I wanna say is when we hear what the members say about haechan’s personality we typically hear the same things pretty consistently. I think when mark is talking about haechan “never being like this off camera” he’s talking more specifically about certain actions and traits he puts on when on camera vs when he’s off camera, rather than insinuating haechan’s personality is completely different.

With that out of the way, let’s talk about haechan’s astrology because this is the only way I can speak in hypotheticals about his personality!

He has a LOT of Gemini in his chart: Sun, Mars, Venus. While a lot of people might associate Gemini with being two faced, I’d like to call them more adaptable. They might act different with some people over the other, or sometimes they might seem like a whole new person the very next day. These are more so exaggerations, but the point is that geminis typically know how to adapt their multifaceted personalities into situations that call for them. To some friends they can be really funny, vibrant, and energetic, and with others they can be more quiet, introspective, and maybe enjoy some more deeper topics. I think haechan unintentionally/intentionally chooses how to present himself among people based on the situation or just their personalities in general. Perhaps with mark, haechan is a little more reserved in the sense that he rather have mark be the one to engage more so that it’d be easier for him to gage what mark wants/needs. I think he probably finds this to be the most comfortable dynamic between him and mark.

I’ve answered a few variations of this question in the past but I feel like I can better articulate my words without coming off as too complicated: sexuality is complex, so there’s no set placements that can automatically tell you if someone is queer or not. That being said, a lot of modern astrologers have taken notice to specific patterns in queer people’s charts that you /could/ break down and interpret as a sign of a person being part of the lgbtq+ community. It’s less “if you have these placements you are queer” and more “a lot of queer people have these placements” if that makes sense.

So to answer your question…kind of? It’d be much more of a guess than an actual definitive conclusion.

Not to bring everything back to astrology buttttt maybe it’s because haechan’s a Gemini sun and I’m a Gemini Moon and Rising, I feel a sort of understanding with how he presents himself because I see a lot of myself in him. One thing I really like about haechan is that it’s very easy for him to voice his thoughts with confidence and not feel the need to second guess himself. While he may struggle with a lot of unprocessed emotions or personal insecurities, he knows how to set them aside to focus on what’s more important to him in that moment, which can be both a positive and negative. Gemini is a really complex energy, and when you have a stellium it really amps up a lot of a person’s confusion over their identity and sense of self, which…I’m very guilty of. What I really appreciate about haechan is that he allows himself space to question himself and embrace his complexity rather than stress out over it.

I know this isn’t probably how you wanted me to answer this question so I apologize it snowballed into this 😭