It depends on who you ask and how old he is. He gets progressively worse as he ages and loses more people. I typically focus on him in his 30s and 40s, and at that big old age spectrum, I would say... If our range is 1 is an angel and 10 is the devil incarnate, I would put him at about a 6-8, depending on age.

The depth of his awfulness increases, and the worst action he takes at 28 is not as bad as the worst action he takes when he's 48. He ages like fine wine, if the wine enjoys ignoring people's boundaries, manipulating, gaslighting, and abusing people.

But, if you asked his wife, Alice would say he's a 3 or 4. The other members of the Menagerie would have different answers as well. Mia would say he's a 10, and that's why she ends up leaving. Dove would say he's a 6 or 7, but she's horny about it. Elsie would say he's a 1 or 2 because she adores him. Juliette would say he's a 3 or 8, depending on whether a certain horrific incident has happened yet.